Tuesday, December 30, 2008

The "Vacuum"

clipped from www.jewcy.com

A major fallacy ensues from this
one-sided premise, which is that Israel is the sole stimulus for Hamas response, and therefore it alone bears the responsibility for the undeniable
misery in Gaza. Those quick to point out how Olmert's miscalculations have hurt
the people he governs will typically suggest that military incursions
"radicalize" Arab sentiment, leading to more suicide bombers and more
dead Israelis.


Assuming this is true, why is it that the corollary is never
asked: namely, how does Hamas radicalize Israeli sentiment? A much remarked-upon fact of the last 72 hours is that Israel's ultra-left-wing party Meretz
has endorsed Operation Cast Lead, a development that should concern partisans
of both sides. If there is merit to the "root causes" argument, then
surely it applies to the decisions undertaken by a Jewish policy as much
as it does to those undertaken by a Muslim one. Or does a belligerent Israeli
consensus form in a vacuum?