Friday, December 11, 2009

Underwear On Fire -- Pants Already Gone

clipped from wattsupwiththat.com

So as you can see, we really have only one instance where Dr. Jones uses the word “trick” in reference to a procedure on data. There are other uses and variations of the word “trick” in other emails, but only this one instance attributed to Jones where he refers to this data issue.

As Dr. Jones put it: The word ‘trick’ was used here colloquially as in a clever thing to do.

Perhaps, but you’d think we’d see it in general use by Dr. Jones in other emails if it was indeed a colloquialism. In the thousand plus emails we have, there’s no other use of the word “trick” by Dr. Jones that I could find related to data truncation or otherwise, though there are other colloquial uses of the word by other authors.

Add the technical proof that Steve McIntyre has done today:

Which shows that CRU did indeed truncate tree ring data, so that the decline is not shown in the IPCC report as shown in the red line above.